| Role | Actor | Grade |
| Abby Brewster | Nikki Perry | 12th |
| Mrs. Harper | Katelyn Turnbull | 11th |
| Teddy Brewster | Mark Morrison | 12th |
| Officer Brophy | Shane Miller | 12th |
| Officer Klein | Jasmine Stachowski | 9th |
| Martha Brewster | Allison Durkee | 12th |
| Elaine Harper | Amber Durkee | 11th |
| Mortimer Brewster | Mason Harsh | 12th |
| Mr. Gibbs | Coty Lipply | 10th |
| Jonathan Brewster | Anthony Nolfi | 12th |
| Dr. Eistein | Mike Writtenberry | 10th |
| Officer O'Hara | Sydeney Shawgo | 11th |
| Lt. Rooney | Mike Wyatt | 12th |
| Mr. Witherspoon | Aaron Recker | 12th |
